Jamie Carragher acknowledges his past criticism of Casemiro was too strong after the Manchester United midfielder responded to the comments. The Liverpool legend had previously stated Casemiro was past his prime after a match in May 2024. Carragher famously suggested Casemiro retire. Two years later, Casemiro is leaving Manchester United. However, he has shown remarkable improvement under Michael Carrick, scoring nine Premier League goals and helping the club return to the Champions League. When asked about Carragher's comments, Casemiro expressed feeling disrespected. Carragher accepts this criticism but questions if United would sign the 34-year-old again. Carragher said in The Telegraph, that his comments were too harsh. He argued Casemiro should have considered MLS or Saudi Arabian offers. He stated that in 2024, Casemiro lacked the physical ability to compete. Carragher clarified his criticism wasn't personal.